The
Effects of Varying Nitrogen Supply on Common Milkweed (Asclepias
syriaca) Leaf Nitrogen Content and Condition and on Monarch
(Danaus plexippus) Consumption Rates
and Performance
By Beth Lavoie
Master’s Degree Research
Many
monarchs that originate in the Midwestern US come from agricultural
habitats. Pic milkweed in cornfield Monarch per plant densities
in agricultural fields are as high as or higher than densities
in nonagricultural habitats, and even though milkweed densities
are higher in nonagricultural than in agricultural habitats,
more monarchs originate in agricultural habitats because agricultural
fields constitute such a large portion of the landscape (Oberhauser
et al. 2001).
Fertilization
could affect the performance of monarchs that originate in
agricultural habitats. Fertilizer increases the supply of
nitrogen for plants in the fields and generally increases
the plants’ leaf nitrogen content (Mattson 1980). Diet
nitrogen content often affects insect size, development time,
and/or feeding. As a result, it indirectly alters variables
linked to these factors, such as mating success, fecundity,
the onset of diapause, and the time exposed to enemies (review
in Slansky 1993).
To
determine if common milkweed (Asclepias syriaca) from a fertilized
agricultural habitat had higher leaf nitrogen content than
common milkweed from an unfertilized nonagricultural habitat,
I conducted an initial test in early June 2000. I randomly
selected three common milkweed plants in each of two fields
within 1 km of each other near New Richmond, Wisconsin: a
fertilized soybean field and an unfertilized old field separated
by a line of trees. I collected, dried, and milled the topmost
mature leaf from each plant and determined the leaf nitrogen
content (% dry weight) using a Perkin Elmer Series II CHNS/O
Analyzer 2400. The milkweed in the soybean field had significantly
higher leaf nitrogen content (5.28 ? 0.26%) than the milkweed
in the old field (4.20 ? 0.26%) (Mann-Whitney U = 9.0, P =
0.05).
This
finding, combined with the findings that many monarchs originate
in agricultural fields and that the nitrogen content in insect
diets often affects insect performance, led to my questions
about the effects of varying nitrogen supply on monarchs.
I studied how varying nitrogen supply affects common milkweed
leaf nitrogen and monarch consumption rates and performance,
using both glasshouse-grown and field-harvested common milkweed
fed to laboratory-reared monarch larvae.
My experiments are described at the following links:
The Effects of Nitrogen Supply
on Glasshouse-grown Common Milkweed Leaf Nitrogen Content
and Condition and on Monarch Consumption Rates and Performance.
Here, I report how fertilizers with two different amounts
of nitrogen affected the leaf nitrogen and condition of common
milkweed grown in a glasshouse and how feeding on plants from
these two fertilizer treatments affected monarch consumption
rates and performance.
Milkweed
Leaf Nitrogen and Condition and Monarch Survivorship and Performance
in an Agricultural and a Nonagricultural Habitat. Here,
I report the variation in common milkweed leaf nitrogen content
within and between ramets (aboveground stems) from a Wisconsin
old field, the milkweed leaf nitrogen content and condition
in cornfield and nonagricultural roadside habitats, and how
feeding on milkweed harvested from these two habitats affected
monarch survivoral and performance. |

Milkweed
in cornfield
|
References
Mattson,
W. J., Jr. 1980. Herbivory in relation to plant nitrogen content.
Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 11:119-161.
Oberhauser,
K. S., Prysby, M. D., Mattila, H. R., Stanley-Horn, D. E., Sears,
M. K.,
Slansky,
F., Jr. 1993. Nutritional ecology: The fundamental quest for nutrients.
Pages 29-91 in N. E. Stamp and T. M. Casey, editors. Caterpillars:
Ecological and evolutionary constraints on foraging. Chapman &
Hall, New York, New York, USA.
Back
to top | Interactions with Milkweed
| Student/Teacher Research
| Research Topics
| Site Overview
|